D2C 2.0: How Subscription Services Are Steering Automakers Toward Direct Relationships

In the evolving automotive landscape, car subscription services emerge as a game-changing bridge, connecting automakers directly with consumers and redefining the traditional dealership experience.

Michael Higgins

Co-Founder, Managing Director
 @ Loopit.co

Published on 

April 3, 2024


Last updated on 

April 4, 2024

Key Takeaways

  • Car subscription services offer a promising solution for automakers to directly connect with consumers, circumventing traditional dealership networks.
  • These services appeal to younger demographics by offering flexibility and convenience, allowing manufacturers to gather valuable customer data and feedback.
  • While fostering a symbiotic relationship between automakers and dealers, subscriptions challenge the automotive industry to reconsider the future role of dealerships.

In a world where immediacy and customization reign supreme, the automotive industry finds itself at a crossroads. Traditional sales models, extensively built around dealership networks, are facing an unprecedented challenge from the direct-to-consumer (D2C) approach pioneered by Tesla.

This electric vehicle behemoth has effectively redefined what purchasing a car looks like, offering a seamless buying experience directly to the consumer and, in the process, setting a new standard that many traditional automakers aspire to achieve.

The Challenge of Implementing a Direct-to-Consumer Model

However, the transition towards a Tesla-like business model is anything but straightforward for legacy automakers.

The primary hurdle?

An entrenched network of dealers, who have heavily invested in becoming the customer-facing point of sale for automakers, are concerned about the role they will play in the sales process—a sentiment that has influenced legislation against direct sales in various jurisdictions.

This standoff places automakers in a dilemma: innovate to meet the evolving consumer expectations or adhere to the traditional dealership model that has defined the automotive sales landscape for decades.

How Car Subscriptions Introduce a D2C Pathway for Automakers

Amidst this seemingly insurmountable impasse, a novel solution is gaining momentum: car subscriptions. This model isn’t entirely new—luxury brands like Porsche have already ventured into subscription services with programs such as Porsche Drive.

These services are not just another way to drive a vehicle; they represent a paradigm shift in how ownership is perceived. For a monthly fee, subscribers get access to a fleet of cars, insurance, maintenance—essentially, the full spectrum of car ownership responsibilities, minus the long-term commitment.

What makes subscriptions particularly enticing is their appeal to younger demographics, who often favor flexibility and convenience over ownership. This shift allows automakers to foster direct relationships with their customers, bypassing the dealership in the process of vehicle provision, maintenance, and insurance.

It's a model that has been met with enthusiasm, given the increased control it offers manufacturers over the customer experience and the wealth of data and feedback it generates.

Major manufacturers are progressively integrating subscription models into their offerings, recognizing not just the potential to sidestep dealer resistance, but also the opportunity it presents to explore D2C sales in a less confrontational manner.

Improving Manufacturer-Dealer Relations with Subscription Models

While dealers have expressed apprehensions, fearing marginalization, the reality is more nuanced. Subscriptions can, in fact, generate additional showroom traffic and increase revenue from servicing vehicles, suggesting a symbiotic relationship rather than a zero-sum game.

Does this mean that subscriptions are the magic bullet for automakers aspiring to emulate Tesla's direct sales success? Not necessarily. The model presents a promising compromise, offering benefits to both manufacturers and dealers.

Consumers enjoy unprecedented flexibility and a closer relationship with the brands they love, manufacturers gather invaluable insights directly from their end-users, while dealerships adapt to fulfill new roles in servicing and managing subscription fleets.

However, this arrangement raises significant questions about the future of automobile retail. As consumers grow accustomed to the convenience and direct brand engagement offered by subscriptions, will the traditional dealership model need to evolve, or will it risk obsolescence?

The answer remains uncertain, but what is clear is that the automotive sales landscape is undergoing a significant transformation—one where the ultimate winners will be those who can adapt to the changing expectations of the modern consumer.

As the debate between direct sales and dealership networks continues, car subscriptions emerge not as a detour, but as a bridge towards a new era of automotive retail.

This delicate balancing act between innovation and tradition highlights the industry's potential for transformation, ensuring that all parties—automakers, dealers, and consumers—stand to gain from the shift towards a more flexible, consumer-centric approach.

The road ahead is fraught with challenges, but also ripe with opportunity for those willing to embrace change.

About the author
Michael is the co-founder and managing director at Loopit, a SaaS platform specialising in new mobility initiatives such as car subscription, rideshare and digital rental solutions. When he’s not launching new businesses, Michael enjoys motorsports, racing cars himself as well as boating.
Join our mailing list
Thank you for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

Recent Articles

Big Or Small, Loopit grows with your ambitions

Loopit is the technology between car subscription and your fleet potential.